Episode 303 | Feeling Guilt After Your ACL Injury

Show Notes:

In this episode, we talk about the question many ACL athletes ask, usually late at night and usually while replaying the moment it happened. We hear a list of reasons on calls all the time, and we watched a very public moment recently that made us think about how badly our brains want an answer. Some of what sits on that list deserves attention, and some of it might be quietly costing you more than the injury itself. We also look at one situation where looking backward is actually fair game. So what do you do with a question that may never get a clean answer?

 

What is up team? We have a quick one today, and I am going to keep it quick because I know I have had some lengthy ones. Today, I want to talk about something I hear often on calls with ACLers as we dig into their ACL history and discuss how they tore their ACL. More specifically, people often start explaining why they think it happened.

We are going to set aside ACL tears involving obvious contact. Maybe you ran into a tree while skiing, someone collided with you, or another player slide-tackled you into the side of your knee. In those situations, there is an identifiable external event that caused the injury. We are going to focus more on non-contact ACL tears, where nobody was around you and the injury happened during a movement, sport, or activity.

When this happens, many ACLers have a list in their heads of possible reasons why it occurred. You might have a list like this yourself. You may have already started connecting certain events or decisions to your injury, trying to figure out what you could have done differently.

You may have seen the news about Aidan Hutchinson, the Detroit Lions defensive lineman, who reportedly tore his ACL after jumping. I remember watching it live. He had just sacked Drake May of the New England Patriots, jumped into the air to celebrate, and landed. Immediately, you could see something was wrong. He dropped down, grabbed his knee, and eventually came off the field and went to the locker room.

What stood out to me was that this was a player who had already put his knee through much larger loads, higher speeds, greater velocities, and significant forces, play after play. He had access to equipment, resources, and the support needed to maintain an elite level of physical preparation. Yet, after all those repetitions, a jump during a celebration was when the injury happened.

The goal here is not to discuss football or speculate about why his injury occurred. I am bringing him up because of what situations like this do to our brains. We want a reason why something happened. We want to connect the dots and find an explanation, but I am not going to sit here and speculate about why he tore his ACL.

You will see people online making claims about what caused the injury. They might say he was not doing a particular type of training or that a certain program could have prevented it. Some people even claim that their training can fix everything, but that simply does not exist. There are multiple factors involved in an ACL injury, and we cannot reduce every injury to one specific explanation.

Here are some of the things I hear when people talk through their injury history. They might say, “I did not warm up before that game. I played a game the day before, so I was tired. I was traveling that week.” Others say they had not played for a while and jumped straight back into it. Maybe they strained something four or eight weeks earlier and never properly rehabilitated it, or they did not sleep well.

Then comes the sentence that gets me every time: “If I had just done that one thing differently, maybe this would have never happened.”

First, that is normal. Anytime something goes wrong, our brains start looking for the cause. We are wired to think in terms of cause and effect. A plus B equals C. We want to rationalize what happened so our brains can understand it, connect the events, and make sense of something that can feel frightening and unpredictable.

I did this after both of my ACL tears. I tried to figure out what I could have done differently, especially after my first non-contact tear. Could I have trained differently? Could I have done something better from a performance standpoint? Should I have recovered a little better? These are questions I still think about.

I am not judging that thought process because I believe everyone naturally goes through it. It does not matter how much experience you have or whether you work in this field. Even physical therapists who treat ACL injuries can find themselves thinking about what they could have done differently. We all try to identify the connection between what happened and why it happened.

However, I want to help you sort through that list because not everything on it deserves the same amount of weight. I look at these potential explanations in three different buckets.

The first bucket includes things nobody can definitively tie to your ACL tear. Honestly, this makes up most of the list. Particularly with non-contact injuries, nobody can look back at one specific detail and confidently say that it was the reason your ACL tore.

I will debate people on this because I do not believe there is one single explanation for every ACL injury. This includes discussions around Q angles in female athletes or menstrual cycles. Could there be a connection? Possibly. But we need to zoom out and consider the bigger picture, including the cultural and sporting expectations placed on female athletes. For example, how quickly they are expected to return to activity and how rapidly their bodies are expected to adapt compared with their male counterparts.

That is a separate discussion, but the larger point remains: it is incredibly difficult to identify one specific factor and say that it caused an ACL tear. I cannot do that. Your surgeon cannot do that. Even the best researcher in the world cannot do that with certainty. If we had that level of information, we would probably be much closer to solving ACL injuries and re-injuries, but we are not there yet, despite ACL injuries being among the most researched topics in the world.

The guilt you are carrying may be attached to something that has very little evidence behind it. I want you to hear that. You may be blaming yourself for a particular decision or circumstance without actually knowing whether it had anything to do with your injury.

The second bucket includes things that might have contributed a little. Maybe being run down nudged things in the wrong direction. Maybe fatigue played a role. I am not going to tell you that none of these things matter because that would not be honest either. But a small nudge is not the same as pulling the entire trigger. One item on your list did not necessarily flip a switch and cause the injury by itself.

The third bucket is the unknowable. Sometimes your body experiences a certain load, in a particular position, at a particular moment, and that is when the injury happens. There is no checklist item that can explain it. Sometimes that is simply the answer.

As I have said before, if you have kids, please mute this part: sh*t happens. Everyone knows that phrase, and it exists because we cannot always explain the reasoning behind everything that happens in life. The same is true with injuries and ACL tears. We cannot always establish a clear cause and effect, and sometimes the injury cannot be explained by one, two, or even three specific reasons.

Think of an ACL injury as a pie chart. There are different factors that may contribute, and each factor represents a different slice of the pie. The size of each slice can vary from person to person. The factors affecting a mother with two kids who plays recreational sports once a week may look very different from those affecting a high-performing businessperson who travels every week, a college soccer player, or a high school recreational athlete.

Everyone has a different life, activity level, training history, and set of circumstances. We could line up 100 people with the same type of injury and even the same surgical procedure, but the factors that contributed to each injury could be weighted very differently. That is what makes this so challenging. We know there are factors that contribute to ACL injuries, but we do not have one universally defined factor that explains every case.

The story in your head may feel like evidence, and I do not want to dismiss what you are thinking or feeling. But it is still a story your brain has created to make something frightening feel as though it had a clear reason.

There are two additional things that can change how much weight you should give that list. The first is whether your injury was contact or non-contact. If someone hit your knee or you ran into a tree, there may be nothing you could have done to prevent that particular event. It is like a car getting hit on the highway. Non-contact injuries involve more factors, but even then, most of the time, we cannot know exactly why they happened.

The second consideration is whether this was your first ACL tear or your second or third. If this is your first tear, I would encourage you to let that list go. You are unlikely to solve the question of why it happened, and chasing an answer can cost you energy and create unnecessary mental stress.

If this is your second or third tear, that is a different conversation. There are real things we can look at. Were you tested before returning to sport? Did you follow a proper rehabilitation plan? Did you meet the necessary criteria before returning? Did you follow a graded progression back into the sports or activities you wanted to do? Did you maintain an appropriate level of strength and physical performance after returning?

These are factors we can audit after a re-injury. This is where I believe we have a much greater opportunity to identify things that may have been missing or not fully addressed. I am not saying every second or third ACL tear happened because someone did something wrong. But there are cases where something in the rehabilitation or return-to-sport process was not fully dialed in, and that could have contributed.

That is where reflection and introspection can be useful. You can look back at the process, identify areas that may need improvement, and take control of the things that can influence your next recovery. The goal is not to blame yourself. It is to understand what you can learn and apply moving forward.

What do I actually want you to do with the guilt or the things you have been blaming yourself for?

Number one: Reflect once, then close the notebook. Give yourself a short window to think about what happened. Write down anything that feels real or worth considering, and then close the notebook. Do not keep reopening it periodically just to look at the same list or sit with the same questions. Repeatedly revisiting something you cannot definitively answer is unlikely to be productive.

Number two: Turn every “I should have” into a “from here on.” Instead of saying, “I should have warmed up,” turn that into, “My plan will have a warm-up built into it.” If you think you were run down, your next step can be to manage your training load and recovery more effectively. If you believe you were not strong enough, make strength a priority in this rebuild process.

It is the same energy, but now you are directing it toward something you can actually do. Instead of putting all your attention on hindsight, you are using that reflection to make better decisions moving forward.

Number three: Put the rest of that energy into rebuilding. The part you can control is not why the injury happened. It is what you do from today onward. That includes your testing, strength development, rehabilitation criteria, training plan, and progressions. These are the things you can work on to put yourself in the best possible position to make this the last ACL injury you experience.

I know guilt can feel like responsibility. You might believe that if you feel bad enough about what happened, it means you are taking it seriously. But it does not. Taking it seriously means doing the work from here.

That is the perspective I want you to take. Give yourself grace for the things you cannot explain, and hold yourself to a high standard for the things you can control. 

I hope this helps anyone who is carrying even a little bit of guilt about why their ACL injury happened. This can become especially difficult when your rehabilitation is moving slowly, you are experiencing setbacks, or you feel like you are stuck. You start asking yourself, “Why me?” or “Why did this happen?” Then you begin looking back at the injury and wondering what you could have done differently.

Again, if this is your first ACL tear, especially a non-contact injury, I would encourage you to let that go. If it is your second or third, it is fair to audit the process and reflect on what may have contributed. But give yourself grace, and make sure you are doing everything you reasonably can to make this the last one.

Put the time and effort into what you can do as you look forward rather than staying stuck looking backward. Hold yourself to a high standard in the areas you can control, and put yourself in a good position both mentally and physically. Then go do the thing. I think that is incredibly important throughout this process.

We are here to support you in any way. Until next time, this is your host, Ravi Patel, signing off.

Subscribe and leave The ACL Podcast a review – this helps us spread the word and continue to reach more ACLers, healthcare professionals, and more. The goal is to redefine ACL rehab and elevate the standard of care.

     

    Resources:

      • Check out our free ebooks on our Resources page
      • Sign up for The ACL Athlete – VALUE Newsletter – an exclusive newsletter packed with value – ACL advice, go-to exercises, ACL research reviews, athlete wins, frameworks we use, mindset coaching, blog articles, podcast episodes, and pre-launch access to some exciting projects we have lined up
      • 1-on-1 Remote ACL Coaching – Objective testing. An individualized game plan. Endless support and guidance. From anywhere in the world.
      • More podcasts? Check out our archives

      •  

      Connect:

        •  

        Share

        1:1 Coaching   |   Performance Testing   |   Clear Plan   |   Custom Program   |   Return to Sport   |   Community   |   Education   |   Goal Setting   |   Progress Tracking   |   Step by Step Guidance   |   Athlete Support   |   1:1 Coaching   |   Performance Testing   |   Clear Plan   |   Custom Program   |   Return to Sport   |   Community   |   Education   |   Goal Setting   |   Progress Tracking   |   Step by Step Guidance   |   Athlete Support   |   1:1 Coaching   |   Performance Testing   |   Clear Plan   |   Custom Program   |   Return to Sport   |   Community   |   Education   |   Goal Setting   |   Progress Tracking   |   Step by Step Guidance   |   Athlete Support   |   1:1 Coaching   |   Performance Testing   |   Clear Plan   |   Custom Program   |   Return to Sport   |   Community   |   Education   |   Goal Setting   |   Progress Tracking   |   Step by Step Guidance   |   Athlete Support   |   1:1 Coaching   |   Performance Testing   |   Clear Plan   |   Custom Program   |   Return to Sport   |   Community   |   Education   |   Goal Setting   |   Progress Tracking   |   Step by Step Guidance   |   Athlete Support   |   1:1 Coaching   |   Performance Testing   |   Clear Plan   |   Custom Program   |   Return to Sport   |   Community   |   Education   |   Goal Setting   |   Progress Tracking   |   Step by Step Guidance   |   Athlete Support   |   1:1 Coaching   |   Performance Testing   |   Clear Plan   |   Custom Program   |   Return to Sport   |   Community   |   Education   |   Goal Setting   |   Progress Tracking   |   Step by Step Guidance   |   Athlete Support   |   1:1 Coaching   |   Performance Testing   |   Clear Plan   |   Custom Program   |   Return to Sport   |   Community   |   Education   |   Goal Setting   |   Progress Tracking   |   Step by Step Guidance   |   Athlete Support   |   1:1 Coaching   |   Performance Testing   |   Clear Plan   |   Custom Program   |   Return to Sport   |   Community   |   Education   |   Goal Setting   |   Progress Tracking   |   Step by Step Guidance   |   Athlete Support   |   1:1 Coaching   |   Performance Testing   |   Clear Plan   |   Custom Program   |   Return to Sport   |   Community   |   Education   |   Goal Setting   |   Progress Tracking   |   Step by Step Guidance   |   Athlete Support   |   1:1 Coaching   |   Performance Testing   |   Clear Plan   |   Custom Program   |   Return to Sport   |   Community   |   Education   |   Goal Setting   |   Progress Tracking   |   Step by Step Guidance   |   Athlete Support   |   1:1 Coaching   |   Performance Testing   |   Clear Plan   |   Custom Program   |   Return to Sport   |   Community   |   Education   |   Goal Setting   |   Progress Tracking   |   Step by Step Guidance   |   Athlete Support   |   1:1 Coaching   |   Performance Testing   |   Clear Plan   |   Custom Program   |   Return to Sport   |   Community   |   Education   |   Goal Setting   |   Progress Tracking   |   Step by Step Guidance   |   Athlete Support   |   

        Remote ACL Rehab + Coaching

        No more feeling lost. No more settling for what’s down the road. No more letting your insurance be in control.

        You deserve the best care.
        That’s why we created this.
        Just for you.

        Our ACL coaching has been tried and tested by hundreds of ACLers. Rehab and train with us from anywhere in the world. No matter where you are in the process.

        In-Person ACL Rehab + Coaching

        Live near Atlanta? Wanting to take your ACL rehab to the next level with in-person visits? Wanting to work with someone who’s gone through this process twice themselves?

        Say less.

        This is a ACL rehab and coaching experience like you’ve never experienced before.